What’s happened.

On Thursday, October 29, 2026, federal auditor general Karen Hogan released her report on CARM, the Canada Border Services Agency Assessment and Revenue Management system. CARM is the $800-million online tool that bills and collects duties, the taxes charged on goods brought into Canada, on every commercial import. It launched in October 2024. Two years on, the audit found border agency staff still using at least 38 manual workarounds to make it work, including the old software CARM was supposed to replace. Those workarounds ate about 92,000 hours of staff time a year as of June 2026, roughly 50 full-time jobs spent on patching. The agency fields about 19,000 help requests a month and had 4,000 of them unresolved by June 2026. Some took more than 500 days to close.

The audit also said the system does its core job well enough: it processes import declarations. CBSA collected $42 billion in duties and taxes on commercial imports in 2024-25, the federal government’s second-largest source of money after income tax. The agency says the platform is available to users 99 per cent of the time, and that it will retire the workarounds, which were always meant to be temporary. But the report warned the problems “are expected to continue until upgrades are completed and funding shortfalls are addressed,” and said CBSA cannot yet tell whether Canadians are getting value for the $800 million. The system has also become a trade irritant with Washington: U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer named it in his last two annual reports on foreign trade barriers, pointing to the rule that importers based outside Canada must register and post a security deposit before their shipments are released.

For an Alberta business, that is the practical picture. Every imported coil of steel, machine part or piece of field equipment runs through this system, and the duty bill lands there too. If the classification is wrong or the bill is disputed, the question goes into a queue that has taken others more than a year to clear, while the money sits with the government and the goods sit on a dock. At the same time, a Canadian-made alternative skips all of it, which is a selling point most domestic suppliers are not making out loud.

What it means for your business.

If you import steel, components or equipment into Alberta, assume the help desk cannot rescue you this year. Check your CARM account and your tariff classifications before your next shipment, keep your own copies of every declaration and duty payment, and set aside cash in case a disputed bill sits unresolved for months. If you make or stock your product in Canada, say so in your quotes: no duty line, no border hold, no waiting on a government ticket is a real promise to a contractor or procurement buyer working to a schedule.

Next step: This week, pull your last six months of import declarations and confirm every tariff classification yourself before the next shipment ships.

Explore this opportunity for your business

Sources & context.

Reported developments are separated from MKTGSpace’s suggested commercial next steps. Reconfirm current conditions before acting.

See where you fit.

Tell us what you sell. We will come prepared to discuss where your offer fits, who to reach and the marketing strategy and implementation needed to pursue the opportunity.

Talk to us about this signal